Go Back Up

Background Screening ROI Calculator

Calculate the strategic business impact of professional screening services on your organization

💡

How this works: Adjust the sliders below to match your organization's situation. We'll show you the financial impact, time savings, and strategic business value of outsourcing background screening.

Calculation Methodology

Core Assumptions

Working hours per year 1,650 hours
Employer overhead (NI, pension, office) 35% above base salary
Average days to complete screening (in-house) 14 days
Average days to complete screening (outsourced) 5 days

Bad Hire & Quality Metrics

Bad hire rate reduction 50% improvement (8% → 4%)
Bad hire cost multiplier 1.6× annual salary
Screening quality improvement 40% reduction in errors

Hidden Cost Calculations

Manager time per bad hire 17 hours (PIPs, coaching, exit)
Team productivity loss per bad hire 40% of role salary (6-month impact)

Rationale: Bad hires consume significant management time through performance improvement plans, coaching sessions, and exit documentation. Additionally, poor performers typically operate at 60% effectiveness for ~6 months before termination, creating a 20% annual productivity loss. Manager salary is estimated at 1.5× base HR salary.

Compliance Incident Metrics

Manual screening error rate 5% (incomplete/missing checks)
Professional screening error rate 0.5% (quality-controlled)

Rationale: Compliance incidents include incomplete DBS checks, missing right-to-work documentation, expired screening certificates, inadequate reference verification, and GDPR documentation gaps. Manual processes average 1 error per 20 screenings; professional providers reduce this to 1 per 200 through systematic quality controls, automated reminders, and audit trails. Each incident requires 4-8 hours of remediation plus potential regulatory exposure.

Note: These are UK market averages based on industry data and conservative estimates. Your actual figures may vary depending on your specific processes, industry requirements, and provider quality. We recommend using this calculator as a directional tool for internal planning and discussing specific scenarios with screening providers.

Your Organisation

Tell us about your hiring activity and HR team

Number of hires per year 250
10 2,000
How many new employees do you onboard each year?
HR team size handling screening 2
1 person 10 people
How many HR/admin staff manage background checks?
Average HR team member salary £32,000
£24k £55k
Typical annual salary for HR coordinators/administrators
Average role salary (for vacancy cost) £35,000
£20k £100k
Average salary of roles you're hiring for

Process & Costs

Admin time, screening costs, and quality metrics

Hours per hire (current in-house process) 3.5h
1.5h 8h
Time your team spends coordinating checks, chasing responses, and processing results per candidate
Hours per hire (with outsourcing) 0.5h
0.2h 2h
Time needed to submit request and review completed report when a provider handles everything
Screening package cost per hire £55
£30 £120
Typical outsourced screening package cost (basic to enhanced DBS, right to work, references)
Current bad hire rate (%) 8%
2% 20%
Percentage of hires that leave within first year or underperform significantly

Strategic Business Impact

See the full value of outsourcing across key business metrics

HR Time Recovered
£19,635
750 hours your team gets back per year
Equivalent to 0.45 FTE
Time to Hire Improvement
9 days
Faster completion reduces candidate drop-off
2,250 days eliminated annually
Vacancy Days Eliminated
2,250
Days positions filled faster
£30,137 in vacancy costs avoided
Cost Per Hire Reduction
£78
Reduction per hire including all costs
From £147 to £68 per hire
💡 What This Means for Your Business
Strategic Capacity Gained
Your team recovers 750 hours per year—enough to hire a part-time HR coordinator (0.45 FTE). This capacity can be redeployed to proactive retention programs, employer branding, or talent development initiatives that directly impact business performance.
Faster Hiring Reduces Vacancy Impact
By completing screening 9 days faster, you eliminate 2,250 vacancy days annually. That's £30,137 in lost productivity avoided—critical in competitive hiring markets where speed wins talent.
Total Annual Savings
£19,635
Net benefit after screening investment
Efficiency ROI
115%
Every £1 spent returns £2.15
3-Year Value
£58,905
Projected cumulative savings
Hidden Cost Elimination
£45,250
Management time and team productivity saved
From preventing 10 bad hires
💡 Understanding Hidden Costs
Beyond Direct Savings
Beyond the direct time and cost savings, preventing bad hires eliminates significant hidden costs. Each poor performer consumes an average of 17 hours of management time through PIPs, coaching, and exit processes, plus creates a 40% productivity drag on team output during their tenure. This hidden cost is often overlooked in traditional ROI calculations.

Annual Cost Breakdown

Comparing total screening costs by approach

Managing Checks In-House £0
Check processing & fees £0
HR team time to manage process £0
Your team spends 0 hours managing the entire screening process
With Professional Screening Service £0
Screening service & fees £0
HR team time (submit & review only) £0
Provider handles everything; your team spends just 0 hours
Bad Hire Cost Avoided
£112,000
Annual risk reduction from better screening
10 bad hires prevented per year
Compliance Risk Reduction
40%
Fewer errors, better documentation, audit-ready records
Professional-grade compliance
Quality Improvement
95%
Screening completeness & accuracy
vs ~70% with manual processes
Compliance Incidents Prevented
11
Critical screening errors avoided annually
Each incident requires 4-8h remediation
🛡️ Risk Mitigation Impact
Bad Hire Prevention
Professional screening with better reference checks and verification reduces your bad hire rate from 8% to approximately 4%. Based on your hiring volume, that's 10 bad hires prevented annually, saving an estimated £112,000 in replacement costs, lost productivity, and team disruption.
Compliance & Audit Readiness
Manual screening processes are prone to human error and inconsistent documentation. Professional providers maintain audit-ready records, ensure GDPR compliance, and reduce regulatory risk—critical for industries with strict hiring standards.
Compliance Incidents Prevented
Professional screening prevents an estimated 11 compliance incidents annually—incomplete background checks, missing right-to-work documentation, or expired certificates that could trigger audit findings or regulatory scrutiny. Each incident requires 4-8 hours of remediation time plus potential regulatory exposure.

Methodology Note: This calculator uses UK market averages and conservative estimates for bad hire costs (1.6× annual salary), vacancy costs (daily salary ÷ 260 working days), manager time (17 hours per poor performer), team productivity impact (40% of role salary), and error rates (5% manual vs 0.5% professional). Compliance incidents include incomplete checks, missing documentation, and process errors based on industry benchmarks. Hidden costs reflect management time and team productivity impact from bad hires. Your actual results may vary based on your specific processes, industry requirements, and provider services. We recommend using this as a directional tool for internal planning and discussing specific scenarios with screening providers.